Two different questions get tangled here. First, does Social Security count as income for IRMAA? Only the taxable portion of your benefits does. Second, how is IRMAA paid? If you collect Social Security, the surcharge is usually withheld straight from your monthly check. This guide separates the two so you know what raises your surcharge and what simply pays it.
IRMAA is based on your MAGI, which is your adjusted gross income plus any tax-exempt interest. Social Security benefits only enter that number to the extent they are taxable. The taxable portion of your benefits sits inside your AGI, so it counts. The non-taxable portion never reaches your AGI, so it does not count toward IRMAA at all.
This is an important distinction. Many retirees assume their entire Social Security benefit counts against the IRMAA income thresholds. It does not. Only the slice the IRS treats as taxable does.
The taxable share depends on what the IRS calls your combined income: your AGI, plus any tax-exempt interest, plus half of your Social Security benefits. The more other income you have, the larger the taxable share of your benefit becomes, up to a ceiling.
Because that taxable amount is what flows into MAGI, the same other income that makes more of your benefit taxable also tends to be what drives your IRMAA. For the full picture of what feeds MAGI, see what counts as MAGI.
Yes, for most people. If you are collecting Social Security, your Part B premium and any IRMAA surcharge are deducted from your benefit before it is paid, the same way the standard premium is. You do not write a check. You just see a smaller net deposit.
Your gross benefit does not shrink. The surcharge is a withholding from it, not a cut to the benefit itself. If your monthly benefit is too small to cover the surcharge, or you have not started collecting Social Security yet, Medicare bills you directly instead.
It is uncommon. Since no more than 85 percent of a benefit is taxable, Social Security by itself usually does not lift a MAGI over a threshold. In most cases the surcharge comes from other income stacked on top: required minimum distributions, pension income, a Roth conversion, or a large capital gain. Social Security is often the smaller piece of the total.
IRMAA looks at your income from two years ago. If a recent event has reduced your income, such as retirement or the death of a spouse who also received benefits, you may be able to ask Social Security to use your lower current income. See the life-changing events that qualify and how to appeal IRMAA.
Source: taxability of Social Security benefits and the combined-income thresholds per IRS Publication 915; MAGI for IRMAA and benefit withholding per SSA publication 05-10536. Informational only, not financial or tax advice. Last verified June 2026.